During both proceedings, the state acknowledged their evidence was all circumstantial, and they could not establish a motive scharmel would receive no part of burnetts estate. All charges dropped against baltimore officers in freddie. Porter superior court judge roger bradford handled the trial. A baltimore police officer will stand trial for a second time in the death of freddie gray. Prosecutors have indicated that testimony from officer william porter, whose trial ended in a hung jury last month, is crucial to. The crowds were peaceful after the judge declared a mistrial in william porters trial. A fellow baltimore police officer has taken the stand as prosecutors continue to argue their case against officer edward nero, one of six officers charged in the arrest of freddie gray, in his. New jersey senators bribery trial ends in hung jury. The grand jury indicted porter on all charges and added an indictment of reckless endangerment.
For baltimore, justice for freddie gray is bigger than. Erik galen menendez, hazel thornton updates her book. Valparaiso mans molestation trial ends in hung jury. And now the first trial has ended just as quickly, with a judge declaring a mistrial because of a hung jury, following only three days of deliberation. A boy reads a book he picked out during a giveaway organized by. The third trial, a second attempt to prosecute wilde after the hung jury of the second trial, opened on may 22. More than two decades after serving as a juror on the highprofile sevenmonth murder trial people v. Baltimore wrestles with the way forward after a mistrial the new. A judge declared a hung jury after panel couldnt reach a decision in freddie gray trial. This collection consists chiefly of letters and scrapbooks related to the guiteau trial. Tour for oprah book club pick american dirt canceled amid controversy. William porters trial was the first test of prosecutors case against six officers in a city struggling to rein in violent crime. The first freddie gray trial, of officer william porter, ended in a hung jury and a mistrial was declared.
The trial ended with a hung jury in 2007 and porter left office before a second trial. But the federal judge ruled that the jury could not be told any of this. In what is a perceived legal blow for prosecutors, the jury was hung and the judge declared a mistrial in the trial of baltimore police officer william porter in the. District judge william walls declared a hung jury after more than six full days of deliberations that had. Deputies from baltimore city sheriffs office stand outside the courthouse after a mistrial was declared in the trial of william porter. Retrial for officer charged in freddie grays death set for june. Despite the governments attempt to railroad the embassy protectors, the jury did not convict. Information leaked from the jury trial of baltimore police office william porter indicates that the jury was one vote away from acquitting him of the involuntary manslaughter before the hung jury l. A porter superior court judge declared a mistrial wednesday night in the molestation case against a valparaiso man after his jury failed to.
The trial of officer william porter ended in december with a hung jury. Porter, whose first trial ended in a hung jury, is the only officer who did not face administrative charges. Hung jury in first trial for police killing of freddie gray by tom hall 17 december 2015 barry williams, the presiding judge in the first trial over the police killing of freddie gray, declared a. During both proceedings, the state acknowledged their evidence was all circumstantial, and they could not establish a motive. The trial of officers charged with killing freddie gray has moved quickly all along. Judge resists throwing book at porter county courthouse vandal. Freddie grays family call for calm as officer william porter walks. Today a more subtle approach is used to break a deadlocked jury.
The judge dismissed the jury in the involuntary manslaughter trial of officer william porter the first of six officers to be tried in grays death after 16 hours of deliberations during. Again, friends urged wilde to flee the country, but he wrote to lord alfred that he did not want to be called a coward or a deserter. Hung jury declared in hebron christian academy teachers trial. On friday, in brianna carters first period, 10th grade social studies class at digital harbor high school the trial provided a chance to talk about central themes in her class, like due process and the. But the trial of the first officer charged in the case ended with a hung jury, and city officials said they were doing all they could to prevent a repeat of the chaos and turmoil that gripped the. Officers edward nero and caesar goodson were acquitted by baltimore circuit judge barry williams in may and june, respectively. He was the first of six officers charged in the case to go on trial. Officer william porters trial ended in a hung jury last december.
New trial set for officer william porter in freddie gray. District judge william walls declared a mistrial after more than six full days of deliberations failed to produce a. And now the first trial has ended just as quickly, with a judge declaring a mistrial because of a hung jury, following only three days of. Jury selection was stopped and the case was put on hold while the second highest court in maryland decides whether officer william porter, whos own trial ended in a hung jury, can be forced to. Jurors deliberated for more than two hours before the jury was declared hung in the trial of jennifer mcleod, of wheatfield. City teachers and students braced for a verdict in porters trial last week, but it ended wednesday with a hung jury and a mistrial.
Jury selection for goodsons trial was supposed to start monday. Judge declares mistrial of baltimore cop in freddie gray. The jury which was composed of seven black and five white people, failed to reach a verdict over officer william porters alleged involvement. The restarted trials come after officer porters trial ended in a hung jury in december, and the city wandered through months of arguments about whether officers could be compelled to testify. This article is more than 4 years old on wednesday, the trial of baltimore police officer william porter ended in a hung jury. The prosecutor brought charges with nearly unprecedented speed, within two weeks of grays death. Baltimore on edge after hung jury in policemans manslaughter trial.
Judge declares mistrial in baltimore police case after jury. Five other policemen are due to stand trial in january. Trial of baltimore police driver in freddie gray death to. When taking the witness stand in goodsons trial for two hours. A hung jury wednesday in the first freddie gray trial in baltimore could affect the prosecution of other police in the case. The life of baltimore icon miss tony and the death of.
Baltimore police van driver acquitted of all charges in freddie gray case. University of maryland law professor david gray said prosecutors typically indicate they will retry a defendant after a hung jury. Porter also prosecuted john bradley crawford on a charge of murdering 6yearold alexander paul glanz in 1980. Williams declared a mistrial in the criminal case of officer william porter because the jury was unable to reach a unanimous verdict. The letters are primarily from private citizens or citizen groups urging porter to end the trial quickly and have. In times long gone by, when a jury was unable to reach a verdict the trial court simply deprived the jurors of food, water, and fire until it reached a verdict. Jury was one vote away from acquitting william porter of. Officer william porter trial hung jury on all 4 charges. The 4day trial ended in a hung jury and declaration of mistrial. Lessons from officer william porters mistrial in the freddie gray. The indiana constitution article 1 section 19 provides for a. Arresting officer charged in freddie gray case chooses a trial before a judge instead of jury. First cops trial in freddie gray case ends with hung jury. Porter was accused of four charges including manslaughter in the.
He covers county government and courts in porter county, federal courts, police news and regional. Porter was the prosecuting attorney in the extended and controversial trial of charles guiteau, the assassin of president garfield. It is now up to states attorney marilyn mosby to determine whether to further pursue criminal charges. On december 16, 2015, a mistrial was declared on all charges, after the jury was hung and could not come to a decision. Unlike the first trial against porter, which ended in a hung jury. Baltimore the states attorney here dropped all remaining charges wednesday against three city police officers awaiting trial in the death of freddie gray, closing the book on one of the. Demonstrators protest outside of the courthouse in response to a hung jury and mistrial for officer william porter, one of six baltimore city police officers charged in connection to the death of. He is one of six baltimore city police officers charged in connection with the death of freddie. The judge declared a mistrial on third day of deliberations in porters trial, which is the first of six trials of police officers involved in the death of. The judge declared a mistrial after jurors said they remained deadlocked in the case of baltimore police officer william g. The trial of william porter, which ended in a hung jury, marked the first time a police officer faced charges for one of a series of highprofile deaths of black men nationwide.
Jury hears closing arguments during trial of william. A jury deadlock occurs when all twelve jurors cannot agree on a verdict. I expected acquittal on the major charges, and perhaps a hung jury on the minor charge of misconduct. Goodson is the third of six baltimore police officers to stand trial. The baltimore sun is reporting that the jury in the recently hung jury of officer william porter was one vote shy of acquittal on the most serious charge of manslaughter when they were finally dismissed in a mistrial, with 11 of 12 jurors voting for acquittal this information purportedly is sourced from one of the jurors who requested anonymity in order to avoid being held accountable for.
But no conviction is still a big setback to the prosecution. The prosecution benefited from the previous trial and won. A hung jury or deadlocked jury is a judicial jury that cannot agree upon a verdict after extended deliberation and is unable to reach the required unanimity or supermajority this situation can occur only in common law legal systems, because civil law systems either do not use juries at all or provide that the defendant is immediately acquitted if the majority or supermajority required for. Peaceful protests took place in response to a hung jury and mistrial for officer william porter, one of six baltimore city police officers charged in connection to grays death. Late last year, a jury couldnt reach a unanimous decision in the case against officer william porter, who checked on gray several times after he was put.
Officer william porters trial has ended in a mistrial. Venezuela embassy protectors on trial dissident voice. Porter, right, whose trial last week ended in a hung jury, will be retried after the other five officers. She stood trial twice, because the first hearing ended in a hung jury. The hung jury is, i think, a major setback for the state, said andrew alperstein, a baltimore defense attorney and former prosecutor. But the william porter trial appeared fair and revealing. Mistrial in case of cop involved in freddie grays death. Hung jury in freddie gray case of baltimore police officer. Ap insights ap definitive source ap images spotlight ap explore ap books. Often referred to as trial by jury, this is a trial in which a jury hears the facts of a case and renders a verdict based on the facts presented to them. Arresting officer in freddie gray case chooses bench trial. Porter laporte county courts and social justice reporter. After a sevenmonth investigation, police arrested scharmel for the murder.
No date yet for new trial in baltimore officers manslaughter trial. The embassy protectors told the police they would leave voluntarily once that agreement was reached. The trial of william porter was the first test of city. Mistrial declared in freddie gray case after baltimore. All american boys takes on race and police violence in. Hung jury in first trial for police killing of freddie.
New jersey senators bribery trial ends in a hung jury. The first trial of officer william porter ended in a hung jury last week. Baltimore police van driver acquitted of all charges in. Students respond to the officer porter mistrial wypr. Hung jury in freddie gray case a major setback for. Porter, 26, was charged in grays death from a broken neck suffered while the 25yearold man was transported in. The trial of officer william porter ended with a hung jury in december.
461 1309 1126 1458 1139 968 900 553 128 586 297 111 1558 1443 710 969 1249 148 1407 163 874 1424 473 731 1194 776 726 1259 325 824 477 1335 999 319 925